A boy who allegedly suffered a shoulder injury at birth has settled a lawsuit in the High Court for € 600,000.
Matthew Meehan, now 12, has balance and coordination issues and therefore misses a lot of sports but is doing very well in school, Liam Reidy SC told court on Tuesday.
The lawyer said their case alleged that “excessive force” was used during a forceps delivery of the boy at Coombe Hospital in Dublin in October 2008. The forceps nearly entered the baby’s eye , did he declare.
Matthew, of Russell Square, Tallaght, Dublin, had, through his mother, Julie Meehan, sued Coombe Women’s & Infants University Hospital, Cork Street, Dublin for the circumstances of his birth on October 8, 2008.
It has been claimed that Ms Meehan was admitted to Dublin hospital on October 8, 2008 to have her second child.
During the instrumental delivery of the baby, it was claimed that he suffered a fractured left collarbone and an injury to his left shoulder, known as Erb’s palsy.
The boy was born at 11:20 p.m. and weighed 4.32 kg. There were forceps marks on his face and scalp, but the baby recovered well, it was said.
The next day he was holding his left arm in a certain way and three days later a physical exam showed a left collarbone fracture which was confirmed by x-ray, it was claimed.
There was no significant improvement in the baby’s elbow or shoulder movement and he later had to undergo a nerve transplant.
It was further claimed that excessive traction was applied to the baby’s neck or shoulder during the forceps delivery, that there was no further maneuver when it was known that the delivery was complicated by shoulder dystocia and the mother’s obstetrical history had not been recorded or taken into account.
The complaints were dismissed.
Judge Kevin Cross approved the settlement.